Why we don’t build 30-page websites for Google

Mass content works until it stops working. What we do instead, and what it costs.

Blog

Forty near-identical pages, or eight written for people Two ways of filling a website, side by side. On the left, forty identical pages generated from a template, one per service and per town, written for a search engine. On the right, eight larger pages, each different from the others, one per real service, written for the people who will read them. Forty near-identical pages, or eight written for people. Two ways to fill a website, and what each one costs. FOR A SEARCH ENGINE One per service, one per town. FOR WHOEVER READS THEM One per real service, and no more. A site that reads like the work is worth more than a site that talks about it.
The choice is between pages that get counted and pages that get read.

Practice websites with thirty or forty near-identical pages are everywhere: one per service, multiplied by every town nearby. The place name changes and nothing else. A clinic does it with every treatment, an architecture studio with every kind of project, a law firm with every practice area.

One template, forty pages On the left, a template page: the town name drops into a placeholder and all the rest of the text is always the same. An arrow leads from that template to a grid of forty generated pages, all with the same layout, where only the name in that placeholder changes. THE TEMPLATE THE GENERATED PAGES Our service in [town] All the rest stays the same. The place name changes, nothing else. One page per service, multiplied by every town nearby. That is how a practice website reaches forty pages.
Forty pages all come out of the same template, and only the place name changes.

Does it work? For a long time it did. That is why, when you search your own sector, the first results are almost always those.

We don’t build that way. It is worth explaining why, without pretending the decision costs nothing.

An eight-page site shows up less on day one

On the day it goes live, a site of eight pages written properly shows up less than a site of forty pages written for a search engine. Fewer pages indexed, fewer word combinations, fewer ways in.

Forty pages are forty ways in. Eight are eight. Anyone who tells you otherwise is selling you optimism.

Three things go wrong with the generated page

It is a page written for one search, and for nobody else.

Nobody updates it. Thirty pages generated from a template are thirty pages the practice never opens again. Two years on, half of them contradict the other half: a service you no longer offer, opening hours that changed, the name of a colleague who left.

It shows. A patient, a client or a competition jury reads two sentences and works out that the text was not written for them. The trust the page was meant to build is the trust it spends.

The target moves. The advantage these pages had came from a search engine that rewarded quantity and exact matching. That engine has changed several times in the last decade and it keeps changing. A site whose only defence is volume is left exposed the day volume stops counting.

The same page, two years on Two panels showing the same generated page. In the first, on the day it goes live, it is intact. In the second, two years on, three marks flag, on the same lines, what stopped being true: a service no longer offered, opening hours that changed and the name of a colleague who left. Below, a note that the search engine that rewarded quantity has changed too. The day it goes live The generated page does its job. [town] More pages, more ways in. Two years on Nobody opened it again. [town] 1 a service no longer offered 2 hours that changed 3 the name of a colleague who left Half contradicts the other half. And the target moves. The advantage came from a search engine that rewarded quantity and exact matching. That engine has changed several times, and it keeps changing.
The page nobody opens again is the page that starts to contradict the practice.

Fewer pages, and the work that is not the site

We write fewer pages, each one for a real person who will read it.

  • One page per real service, not one per service times town.
  • The language your client uses when talking to you, not the language the sector uses when talking to itself.
  • A fast site, readable on a phone, with the essentials in plain view.

Then comes the work that is not the site: the Google business profile filled in properly, the same address and the same number everywhere, photographs that are your own. That is where local demand for a practice is decided, not across forty twin pages.

Two halves of the work: the site, and what is not the site Two stacked boxes. On top, the site: one page per real service, written for whoever reads it, fast and readable on a phone, with the essentials in plain view, in the language the client uses when talking to you. Below, flagged, the work that is not the site: the Google business profile filled in properly, the same address and the same number everywhere, photographs of your own, and that is where local demand for a practice is decided. THE SITE each one for a real person One page per real service Written for whoever reads it Fast and readable on a phone The essentials in plain view The language your client uses when talking to you. OFF THE SITE the work that is not the site The Google business profile filled in properly The same address and number everywhere Photographs that are your own That is where local demand for a practice is decided. Not across forty twin pages.
Local demand for a practice is also decided away from the site.

Where we would be wrong: the volume business

If your business lives on search volume and thin margins, the maths is different. A price comparison site, or a retailer with thousands of product lines, has real reasons to run a mass content strategy.

Tell us, and we will tell you whether we are the right studio. We are not, for everybody.

For anyone who lives on reputation, on referral and on work done well, a site that reads like the work is worth more than a site that talks about it.

Talk to us

Want to know what we would do with your site?